Deciding to save or kill a bird...
Outdoor Ontario

Deciding to save or kill a bird...

Guest · 2 · 1719

mr.sharp-photo

  • Guest
had a blah experience yesterday.
i was leaving my house and i saw some house sparrows look like they were fighting or rolling around the street. i then saw a sparrow try to move/pick up something, so i went to take a closer look. there was an injured sparrow, face down, on the street and it was breathing rapidly. i've never seen a bird lie face down, so i knew it was bad. the sparrow that i saw that was trying to pick it up was clearly distraught.
i went inside and found a shoebox and put on a latex glove. but i had a decision to make:

1. put it in the box and either let it die there?
2. put it in the box, call the city and know that there was zero priority for coming to put a house sparrow out of its misery?
3. break the bird's neck and end the suffering

my neighbour saw what i was doing and we both had a hard time deciding what to do. before i went to the bird, that other house sparrow had tried to pick up the injured bird and move it. i've never seen sparrows act like they care about anything other than depleting my feeder. so i approached the bird who, at this point, had spread one of its wings and looked like it had tried to fly. i put on the glove and decided how i was going to move the bird into the box. i put my hand underneath the bird and it didn't really respond negatively to what i was doing, which i took as a bad sign. i was deciding if i should put my hands on either side of its wings and pick it up from the top or try to get underneath. i decided to try to shovel it up from underneath and when i did, it tipped over to its side, let out one last breath, had a foot twitch and died. so maybe it had a broken neck and my movement put it out of its misery? who knows....

but yeah, playing god kind of sucks.
« Last Edit: December 31, 1969, 07:00:00 PM by Guest »


Trillian Flummox

  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 349
    • http://birdquirks.tumblr.com
Oh Richard - what an awful experience for you!  I think you did the right thing by trying to help, but if the final decision hadn't been made for you, I really don't know what you should have done. Ending an animal's suffering always sounds like the humane thing to do but no doubt it is the most difficult - I don't know if I could do it myself.  At the very least, removing it from the road to a more natural environment may have at least given it some dignity and reduced it's fear until the end. Perhaps someone else here with experience could give us all some practical advice about these types of situations. How do you quickly and humanely kill a bird if it's the only choice?  The only similar experience I've had involved a Herring Gull many years ago. I was walking down a path from my old house when I heard a sickening thud behind me. Turning around I found a Herring Gull lying conscious but bloody on the path - to this day I can't imagine what happened to make him drop out of the sky like that. Perhaps because of his large size, I couldn't cope with the idea of killing him myself.  I scooped him up with a towel, placed him in a box and drove him to the Toronto Humane Society which was only a few minutes from my house. No doubt he was likely euthanized quite quickly. Maybe if I hadn't been such a coward I could have ended his suffering sooner.

Anyway, welcome back to town.

-kris
« Last Edit: December 31, 1969, 07:00:00 PM by Guest »