Pigeons
Outdoor Ontario

Pigeons

Bird Brain

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 2448
    • http://www.spnc.ca/
So, I used to call them Pigeons then the name was changed to Rock Dove now it's changed to Rock Pigeon? Just trying to keep my field guides updated.  I still remember when the name Oldsquaw was changed to Long-tailed Duck.  Apparently birds named after people are going to have their names changed at some point as well?  Good grief, sort of like street names changing too.


Back to Pigeons... have seen some with beautiful unique colouring/plumage.  One in my neighborhood has very unusual black + white markings.   :D
Jo-Anne :)

"If what you see by the eye doesn't please you, then close your eyes and see from the heart".


Shortsighted

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 3241
I think that I know what you mean.




Bird Brain

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 2448
    • http://www.spnc.ca/
I think that I know what you mean.


Very pretty!   8)  Now imagine more black markings on the side and back.  Sorry, I don't have a camera.


So far today have seen 2 House Sparrows (1m,1f) in crabapple tree out front of the house.  They are cute little birds.  :)
Jo-Anne :)

"If what you see by the eye doesn't please you, then close your eyes and see from the heart".


Shortsighted

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 3241
Since you're musing about nomenclature I guess it's apropos that the next change in naming is to stop calling the House sparrow "a sparrow". It's provenance as an Old World Weaver finch should resurrect it as a finch here as well.


Dr. John

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 484
I responded about this on another thread.


I don't have a problem with name changes, particularly if the new name is descriptive of the bird's appearance, behaviour, habitat, or something else characteristic.  Having the bird (or any other animal) named for a person isn't really helpful, particularly for the beginner birder.  I've adapted to previous name changes and can handle new ones.


Shortsighted

  • Frequent Users
  • Old Timer
  • *****
    • Posts: 3241
Yes, this is an essential point because naming a bird after some hornythologist does not provide any clue to the phenotype of the species. In the health care profession there are also many conditions, syndromes, diseases and disorders that are named after a researcher or clinician that studied it, thus resulting in eponymous dedication. Never mind Wilson's warbler. What about Wilson's disease! Fortunately in both medicine and ornithology there are also Latin names, or Greek names that are often descriptive if you have some smattering of a dead language. In medicine there are alternate names that are more descriptive making it unnecessary to memorize Wilson's, Huntington's, Kleinfelter's, and Bright's, among many others. If you have a myxoid chondrosarcoma it sort of describes itself once you understand the root words. One does not need to go look up somebody's name to figure out what the disease is all about. The names of birds should be like the Doc says, describes what the bird looks like, or an identifying behaviour. A Mute swan is silent, while a Trumpeter swan honks like a horn. It's not a trombone swan, or a tuba swan, or a saxophone swan even though they are all horns and sounding like all of them at one time or another would just place a swan at risk of being pronounced as a horny swan, which they are at this time of year anyway, but once again I've managed to digress. Oh dear, is it Shortsighted disease? I have an SSD?