I swear Charline, you are a bit of a hero to me. Not only do you come up with good ideas by thinking outside the box but you have the drive to pursue them, although you did give a credit to your club for the adventure. I'm half dead by the time it gets dark from working on building a speaker (project) for my neighbour during the day and you are up and out in the cold winter air, on a ferry to the island in order to search for fluorescence. Fluorescence is about as hard to find as inspiration these days. They don't make em like you anymore. The password of the early 21st century is LAZY. You are certainly as far removed from lazy as it is possible to scale. Maybe you just have a thing for UV light. I get that.
I'm no geologist, or even an apologist, but I think that I get the gist of what you may have found, a piece of fluorescent Syenite, an igneous rock with very little quartz but lots of feldspar (maybe Peristerite) and Sodalite. Not common on the shores of the Great Lakes but there is some around, mostly around L. Superior. The stone with the odd-shaped pale inclusions is porphyry (basalt with phenocryst inclusions) or perhaps andesite, but more likely the first one because it is very common. You do take extra batteries, don't you?